Comparison

First-Party vs Third-Party Intent Data

First-party intent data is what accounts do on your own site and product. Third-party intent data is what a provider saw them do somewhere else. Here is how each is collected and what each is good for.

5 min read

Intent data is evidence that a company is researching a product or a problem. The difference between the two kinds is who saw it happen.

First-party intent data is what you observed yourself: visits to your site, activity in your product, replies to your emails, attendance at your webinars.

Third-party intent data is what someone else observed and sold to you: reading on publisher sites, searches, activity on review sites.

Some people add a middle category, second-party data, for sources such as a review site that shares what buyers did on its own pages. There is no official taxonomy. The categories come from the vendors themselves.

What Each One Tells You

First-partyThird-party
Who collected itYouA data provider
What it showsInterest in youInterest in a topic or a category
Who else has itNobodyEvery customer of that provider
Level of detailPages, events, people who identified themselvesUsually the company, and a topic score
CoverageOnly accounts that already found youAccounts that have never heard of you
Can you check itYes, it is your own logRarely

The short version: first-party data tells you who already knows you. Third-party data is an attempt to tell you who is in the market before they find you.

How Third-Party Intent Data Is Collected

Providers describe a few sources, often in combination:

  • Publisher networks. A group of business websites share which companies read which articles. The provider maps articles to topics and reports companies reading more than usual about a topic.
  • Advertising data. Information that passes through online ad auctions, including the page being viewed and an identifier for the visitor.
  • Review and comparison sites. Which companies looked at which product categories.

How the data was collected matters for more than accuracy. The UK regulator's 2019 report on advertising auctions found that finding a lawful basis for that data was difficult and that the consent collected for it was often insufficient. If a provider's data comes from that source, you inherit the question.

What Buyers of Intent Data Report

In a Forrester survey of intent data users, the top execution challenge was identifying the specific people inside an account that showed intent. A topic score tells you a company is reading about a subject. It does not tell you who to call.

There is also a base-rate problem. The LinkedIn B2B Institute's 95-5 rule is a rough guide and not a measurement, but its point holds: at any moment most of your market is not buying. A signal has to be very good to pick out the few who are, and reading an article is a long way from a purchase. A MarTech column makes the same argument in more detail.

We could not find an independent audit of any provider's accuracy. The figures in circulation are the providers' own.

Questions to Ask a Provider

  1. Where does the data come from, in plain terms?
  2. On what legal basis was it collected, and in which countries?
  3. How old is a signal by the time it reaches you?
  4. How does a topic map to the pages people read?
  5. Can you run a test against accounts you already know are evaluating you?

The last one is the test that matters. Give the provider a list that mixes accounts in an active deal with accounts that went cold, and see whether the scores can tell them apart.

Start With What You Already Have

For most small teams the order is first-party first. It is free, it is yours, and it reflects interest in your product. Add third-party data when you have run out of accounts that already know you and need to find ones that do not.

How Leapio Fits

Leapio works from first-party data: the events on your own site and product, tied to the company behind them, with consent recorded on each event. Signals come from that behavior. Research on outside events such as funding or hiring is something you turn on for specific target accounts. Leapio does not sell third-party intent scores.

Get Started

See Your First Events in Minutes

Free to start, no credit card. Add signals and actions when you are ready.

AI-Native Go-to-Market Analytics That Drives Revenue and Action